Top Bakery Shops for Children's Birthday Cakes on Long Island in the Year 2025
Long Island is home to a plethora of bakeries that specialize in creating unique and personalized custom cakes for various occasions. Here are some of the top bakeries known for their creative designs and handling of everything from weddings to birthdays.
Riesterer's Bakery, West Hempstead
One of Long Island's oldest bakeries, Riesterer's Bakery in West Hempstead is Kosher-certified and offers custom kosher cakes. It is a favourite among locals for its traditional baked goods and custom cake designs.
Francesco's Bakery, Hicksville
Francesco's Bakery in Hicksville is a go-to for cookies, pastries, Italian bread, and custom cakes with unique designs. The bakery's expertise in creating custom cakes has made it a popular choice for those seeking something special for their celebrations.
Sweet Karma Desserts, Plainview
Sweet Karma Desserts in Plainview is an award-winning bakery known for its custom cakes, including options for gluten-free diets. This bakery is a favourite among those who value quality and customization in their desserts.
Buttercookey Bakery (Multiple Locations)
Buttercookey Bakery, a family-owned bakery with locations in Floral Park, Manhasset, and Huntington, offers plentiful cake options, including classic choices for birthday celebrations and unique custom cake designs.
Tulip Bake Shop, Floral Park
Tulip Bake Shop in Floral Park is the oldest continuous small business in the town and is a favourite in the community. It offers cookies, pastries, pies, breads, and cakes, with custom cake designs for birthday celebrations. The bakery can also make gluten-free mini occasion cakes.
Dortoni Bakery, Westbury
Renowned for custom and wedding cakes, Dortoni Bakery has been voted Long Island's Best Wedding Cakes since 2012. The bakery offers elegant and specialty cake designs for various occasions.
Batter Up Bakery, Levittown
Highly praised for not only their cakes but also cookies and donuts, Batter Up Bakery is noted for their phenomenal custom birthday cakes and other baked goods.
Tortafina
Mentioned as one of the best bakeries for custom cakes in Long Island, Tortafina is often credited with popular and trending cake designs, including heart-shaped cakes.
While not located precisely in Long Island, Sweet Delites in Somers offers custom cakes with over 20 years of experience and might be relevant for those near Westchester County with sophisticated custom cake requirements.
St. Rocco's Bakery, Glen Cove
St. Rocco's Bakery in Glen Cove allows customers to create custom cakes with their imagination and also offers breakfast and lunch options.
Fanny Cakes, Nesconset
Fanny Cakes in Nesconset focuses on quality desserts for parties and gatherings, creating custom cakes and couture cupcakes. It offers dessert decorating party packages.
Park Bake Shop, Kings Park
Park Bake Shop in Kings Park offers tiered cakes, sheet cakes, or cupcake cakes, with cupcake cakes being a popular option for children's parties.
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods, West Sayville
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods in West Sayville offers a variety of baked goods, but specific details about custom cakes were not provided in the text.
Patsy's & Son Italian Bakery, Lindenhurst
Patsy's & Son Italian Bakery in Lindenhurst offers Italian pastries, cookies, bread, and cakes, with custom cakes designed to match birthday themes and specialty requests.
Little Sugar Shop, Valley Stream
Little Sugar Shop in Valley Stream offers impeccably designed cakes with various themes and flavours, including Funfetti and Oreo.
Vin's Bake Shop, Massapequa Park
Vin's Bake Shop in Massapequa Park is a family-run bake shop that offers specialty cakes in various designs, such as hybrid fondant and buttercream, naked cakes, and cupcake breakaway cake designs.
Exploring Long Island's diverse bakery scene, one can find a variety of establishments specializing in unique lifestyle offerings. For food and drink enthusiasts, bakeries like Riesterer's in West Hempstead offer custom kosher cakes. Meanwhile, those interested in home and garden décor may appreciate the custom cake designs at Tulip Bake Shop in Floral Park. For shoppers seeking unique and personally tailored items, bakeries such as Francesco's in Hicksville and Sweet Karma Desserts in Plainview are renowned for their custom cakes, creating memorable centerpieces for various celebrations.
